Of all the Basic Instinct ripoffs to roll off the Hollywood assembly line in the ‘90s, none received a worse critical drubbing than Body of Evidence. A lot of the vitriol had to do with the stars involved - Willem Dafoe, cashing a check as the Michael Douglas stand-in, and Madonna, assuming the Sharon Stone role as a femme fatale who enjoys sexing men to death. Look, we’re not going to waste precious brain cells mounting some kind of retroactive contrarian defense of the film. But if you want to understand ‘90s erotic thrillers - and why boys of a certain generation feel slightly uncomfortable whenever mom lights a scented candle - it’s still a vital area of study.
Sex doesn’t sell the way it used to. If you’ve followed the online discourse lately, then you’re aware that cinematic sex – and possibly sex in general – isn’t as popular as it used to be, even among progressive-minded zoomers. Things were different in the 1980s and ’90s, when erotic thrillers ruled. Back then, it seemed like half the movies involved some combination of Michael Douglas, Tom Berenger and Sharon Stone, all thrusting away at one another, before turning around and trying to literally stab each other in the back.
It was truly the glory days of lurid entertainment. And then, sometime around the turn of the millennium, it suddenly ended. It’s hard to say if the country’s puritanical shift is what caused erotic thrillers to fall out of favour. But the last year teased a possible comeback, as the lusty gamesmanship of Challengers, the queer neo-noir of Love Lies Bleeding and the meme-launching Babygirl were among the most buzzed-about films of 2024. For that reason, we’ve decided to revisit (and rank) 40 of the all-time best erotic thrillers. Many of them now register as even sleazier than they did when they first came out – but in this prudish era, that might be the exact reason we love them so much.
Recommended:
🍆 The 101 best sex scenes in movies
😬 The 100 best thriller movies of all-time
😍 The 100 best romantic films of all-time
🕵️ 40 murder mystery movies to test your sleuthing skills to the max
🔥 The 100 best movies of all-time